|
Plagiarism means presenting, as one's own, the words, the
work, or the opinions of someone else. It is dishonest since
the plagiarist offers as her own, for credit, the language,
information, or thought for which she deserves no credit.
Plagiarism occurs when one uses the exact language of someone
else without putting the quoted material in quotation marks
and giving its source. (Exceptions are very well-known quotations,
such as from The Bible or Shakespeare, for example.) In formal
papers, the source is acknowledged in a footnote; in informal
papers, it may be put in parentheses, or made part of the text.
This first type of plagiarism, using without acknowledgement
the language of someone else, is easy to avoid. When a writer
uses the exact words of another writer or speaker, she must
put those words in quotation marks and give the source.
A second type of plagiarism is more complex. It occurs when
the writer presents as her own, the sequence of ideas, the
arrangement of material, or the pattern of thought of someone
else, even though she expresses it in her own words. The language
may be hers, but she is presenting as hers and taking credit
for the work of another. She is, therefore, guilty of plagiarism
if she fails to give credit to the original author of the pattern
of ideas.
Students writing informal themes, in which they are usually
asked to draw on their own experience and information, can
guard against plagiarism by a simple test. They should be able
to honestly answer "No" to the following questions:
- Am I deliberately recalling any particular source of information
as I write this paper?
- Am I consulting any source as I write this paper?
If the answer to these questions is "No," the writer
need have no fear of using sources dishonestly. The material
in mind, which she will transfer to her written pages, is genuinely
digested and her own.
The writing of a research paper presents a somewhat different
problem, for here the student is expected to gather material
from her books and articles read for the purpose of writing
the paper. In the carefully written research paper, however,
(and this is true of term papers in all college courses), credit
is given in footnotes for every idea, conclusion, or piece
of information which is not the writer's own; and the writer
is careful not to follow closely the wording of the sources
she has read. If she wishes to quote, she puts the passage
in quotation marks and gives credit to the author in a footnote;
but she writes the bulk of the paper in her own words and her
own style, using footnotes to acknowldge facts and ideas she
has taken from her readings.
*Saint Mary's College, which has edited
this material, reprints it with the permission of the publisher
from Understanding
and Using English, by Newman P. Birk and Genevieve B. Birk
(Odyssey Press, 1971). |