| Date | Location | Result | |
| Nov 03, 2009 | Grand Rapids, MI | CALVIN 3, Saint Mary's College 1 (25-11,21-25,25-22,25-23) | |
| Oct 31, 2009 | Grand Rapids, MI | Hanover College 3, Saint Mary's College 0 (25-21,25-18,25-17) | |
| Oct 31, 2009 | Grand Rapids, MI | CALVIN 3, Saint Mary's College 0 (25-13,25-4,25-8) | |
| Oct 30, 2009 | Kalamazoo, Mich. | KZOO 3, Saint Mary's College 1 (22-25,25-23,25-17,25-20) | |
| Oct 28, 2009 | Notre Dame, Ind. | Albion College 3, Saint Mary's College 0 (25-22,25-18,25-18) | |
| Oct 23, 2009 | Olivet, Mich. | OLIVET 3, Saint Mary's College 1 (25-21,20-25,25-17,25-23) | |
| Oct 20, 2009 | Notre Dame, Ind. | Hope College 3, Saint Mary's College 0 (25-12,25-13,25-13) | |
| Oct 14, 2009 | Alma, MI | ALMA 3, Saint Mary's College 2 (25-16,23-25,22-25,29-27,15-11) | |
| Oct 10, 2009 | Notre Dame, Ind. | Saint Mary's College 3, Adrian College 1 (25-13,25-16,23-25,25-19) | |
| Oct 09, 2009 | Angola, Ind., | Saint Mary's College 3, TRINE 2 (32-30,17-25,17-25,25-19,15-12) | |
| Oct 06, 2009 | Notre Dame, Ind. | CALVIN 3, Saint Mary's College 0 (25-13,25-22,25-21) | |
| Oct 03, 2009 | Anderson, Ind. | Anderson University 3, Saint Mary's College 0 (25-17,25-20,25-16) | |
| Oct 03, 2009 | Anderson, Ind. | Transylvania Univ. 3, Saint Mary's College 0 (25-21,25-23,25-18) | |
| Sep 30, 2009 | Notre Dame, Ind. | Saint Mary's College 3, KZOO 1 (25-20,26-28,25-23,25-17) | |
| Sep 26, 2009 | Albion, Mich. | Albion College 3, Saint Mary's College 1 (25-23,25-21,18-25,25-21) | |
| Sep 24, 2009 | Manchester College | Saint Mary's College 3, Manchester 0 (25-22,25-15,25-22) | |
| Sep 22, 2009 | Notre Dame, Ind. | Saint Mary's College 3, OLIVET 0 (25-14,25-18,25-14) | |
| Sep 16, 2009 | Hope College | Hope College 3, Saint Mary's College 2 (25-9,25-19,20-25,21-25,15-10) | |
| Sep 12, 2009 | Notre Dame, Ind. | Saint Mary's College 3, ALMA 0 (25-21,26-24,27-25) | |
| Sep 11, 2009 | Adrian, Mich. | Adrian College 3, Saint Mary's College 2 (25-21,15-25,25-17,20-25,15-9) | |
| Sep 08, 2009 | Notre Dame, Ind. | TRINE 3, Saint Mary's College 2 (25-19,23-25,22-25,25-23,20-18) | |
| Sep 05, 2009 | Columbus, Ohio | Saint Mary's College 3, Hanover College 0 (25-18,25-22,25-21) | |
| Sep 05, 2009 | Columbus, Ohio | DePauw University 3, Saint Mary's College 0 (25-17,25-18,25-17) | |
| Sep 04, 2009 | Columbus, Ohio | Saint Mary's College 3, PSU-Altoona 1 (25-23,25-17,20-25,25-21) | |
| Sep 04, 2009 | Columbus, Ohio | Saint Mary's College 3, Muskingum College 2 (19-25,25-16,25-11,23-25,15-8) | |
| Sep 01, 2009 | Notre Dame, Ind. | Bethel College 3, Saint Mary's College 0 (25-21,25-17,25-21) |